Pumpkin Carving Party

Witch’s Cauldron Cider with Shrunken Heads

  1. 1 Cup Lemon Juice

  2. 1 Tbsp. Salt

  3. 4 Granny Smith Apples, Peeled and Halved

  4. 1 Gallon Farmer’s Market Apple Cider

  5. 16 Whole Cloves

Add to My Menu

Creepy Mozzarella Eyeballs

  1. 20 Fresh Ciliegine Mozzarella*

  2. 10 Giant Eagle Small Pimento-stuffed Olives, Halved

  3. 1 Tbsp. Giant Eagle Olive Oil

  4. Dash of Salt and Pepper

Add to My Menu

Alien Tentacle Surprise

  1. 1 Cup Blueberries

  2. 1 Banana

  3. 1 Cup Ice Water, Divided

  4. 1½ Cups Boiling Water, Divided

  5. 2-3 Oz. Boxes Gelatin Mix, Any Flavor

  6. Plastic Wrap

  7. Heavy Duty Aluminum Foil

  8. Newspaper and Masking Tape

Add to My Menu

Spooky Edible Graveyard

  1. 14.3 Oz. Package Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Such as Oreo®

  2. 2 3.9 Oz. Boxes Instant Chocolate Pudding Mix

  3. 8 Oz. Brick Giant Eagle Neufchatel Cream Cheese, Softened

  4. 2½ Cups Giant Eagle Fat-free Milk

  5. 1 Cup Powdered Sugar

  6. 8 Oz. Tub Giant Eagle Frozen Whipped Topping, Thawed

  7. 8 Oblong-shaped Cookies, Such as Milano®

  8. Decorating gel icing “pen”

Add to My Menu